The Love-Hate Relationship with the Word “Gifted” and the Birth of the Rainforest Mind Metaphor

How many of you have said, “I’m not gifted, but I may have a rainforest mind. I answered ‘yes’ to 22 out of 23 questions on your quiz.” Right?

Actually, it might only be a hate relationship. I don’t know anyone who actually loves the word. Or feels that it applies to them. You understand. Perhaps– You don’t feel all that smart. You think gifted only means genius. You believe all humans have gifts so aren’t they all gifted? You know how much you don’t know. You know people smarter than you. You hate how the gifted kids of color are often not identified in schools. You did not excel in school. You never understood math. You were bullied in school because you knew the answers. You are a slow reader. You keep changing jobs once you master the skills. You are not a stunning success at, well, anything, except maybe curiosity. You have a list of achievements but you don’t value them because the accomplishments came easily. You are often anxious and catastrophizing. You have learning disabilities. You forget where you parked your car. Your kids are gifted but you are not.

Even if you admit that you seem to think, feel, and know more deeply and broadly than your cohorts, your sense of justice and your empathy make using the G word about yourself cringe-worthy. And, in your view, maybe even inaccurate. Even though you ask questions no one can answer, you skipped grades in school, you speak five languages, you cry when you hear Jacob Collier lead his audiences in song, your favorite websites this week are Masterclass and Fantastic Fungi, and you collect unusual words for fun (are you bafflegabbing?), you still squirm when someone says you are gifted.

I get it.

So, for those of you looking for an alternative, here ya go. (Disclaimer: This description fits the many gifted folks I have known over the decades. But it is not a totally comprehensive fits-everyone metaphor. It works for the nonlinear creative types, which is many but certainly not all.)

What if we use an ecosystem analogy for humans? What if some are like meadows– sweet, simple, fragrant, and flowery. Some are like deserts– resilient, uniquely beautiful, and deeply rooted. Some like volcanoes– waiting to explode. And some like rainforests– complex, resourceful, colorful, intense, highly sensitive, nonlinear, overwhelming, intelligent, influential, creative, and misunderstood. All ecosystems are necessary and valuable. No ecosystem is better than another. It is just that the rainforest ecosystem is the most complex on the planet. And, I might boldly suggest, these humans are the most complicated, too.

You might relate to a couple brief examples from this post.

Carlos. 42. Self-taught, successful IT expert. Highly sensitive, empathetic, deep thinking, and emotional (although he hides it well). Bullied in school because he preferred grasshoppers and string theory to football. Spends hours writing a three sentence e-mail. Repeats himself often in an effort to be deeply understood and to calm his anxiety. Researches for days in order to make a decision. A slower, deliberate, deep thinker and processor with a quirky sense of humor. Learning to dance the Argentine tango so that he can finally experience being followed.

Frances.  59. After running her own children’s bookstore, raising two kids and their friends, volunteering on the board for the ballet, and remodeling her home, she’s in her latest job working as a city planner. She’s considering going back to school for another Masters degree because she’s always wanted to be an art therapist or a landscape architect or a stand-up comedian. She thinks she’s flakey or shallow because she’s walked so many different career paths. Her sense of social responsibility keeps her awake most nights. Her intuitive abilities frighten her.

And so, my dearest gifted ones, in the book by Xiuhtezcatl Martinez, the tropical rainforest is described:The magnificence of the rain forest is something powerfully sacred, something so clearly worth protecting...the rain forest is one of the most important biomes on the planet for human survival…it offers us an unbelievable abundance of nourishment and resources…” 

You, too, are powerfully sacred and unbelievably abundant. And, yes, so clearly worth protecting.

_________________________________

To my bloggEEs: If you’ve been reading my blog for a while, all this will be familiar. But I realized I didn’t have a simple post that you might share with others as a way to begin the conversation about the G word and your rainforest mind. So, now you do! Of course, my second book, Journey into Your Rainforest Mind, is also a fun way to introduce the topic to friends and family. And, don’t forget, I would love to hear from some of you who are using the new journal. What are you discovering? Can you post a photo of yourself with the journal on social media? I’d love to see you! Thank you, as always, for being here. So much love!

(Note: If I were going to offer a class/group online or a podcast or some sort of audio recordings of my blog posts, which idea appeals to you? I’m a little restless wanting to create something new. Do you have other ideas? But, don’t worry, I will not abandon my trusty blog….or you!)


Author: Paula Prober

I’m a psychotherapist and consultant in private practice based in Eugene, Oregon. I specialize in international consulting with gifted adults and parents of gifted children. I’ve been a teacher and an adjunct instructor at the University of Oregon and a frequent guest presenter at Oregon State University and Pacific University. I’ve written articles on giftedness for the Eugene Register-Guard, the Psychotherapy Networker, Advanced Development Journal and online for psychotherapy dot net, Rebelle Society, Thrive, Introvert Dear, and Highly Sensitive Refuge. My first book, Your Rainforest Mind: A Guide to the Well-Being of Gifted Adults and Youth, is a collection of case studies of gifted clients along with many strategies and resources for gifted adults and teens. My second book, Journey Into Your Rainforest Mind: A Field Guide for Gifted Adults and Teens, Book Lovers, Overthinkers, Geeks, Sensitives, Brainiacs, Intuitives, Procrastinators, and Perfectionists is a collection of my most popular blog posts along with writing exercises for self-exploration and insight.

21 responses to “The Love-Hate Relationship with the Word “Gifted” and the Birth of the Rainforest Mind Metaphor”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


  1. Elena Avatar
    Elena

    Dear Paula, I’m not sure I have the right to speak here, but since no one is making suggestions, I have some ideas for you.
    I think it would be interesting if your bloggers would share their creations: paintings, essays, poems, handicrafts – whatever! Or, for example, Barbara Sher in her book mentioned a site (I didn’t go to it, but perhaps you know) where people share projects that have become uninteresting to them, and I think many people here are familiar with this problem. It would be possible to share ideas or projects that people don’t want/can’t finish. Or, what many of your bloggers might also be interested in, set a topic for the week and brainstorm!
    You may have tried all of this, sorry if I didn’t know.
    As for the online group, I personally will not be able to participate, firstly, because I am not sure that I am gifted, and certainly dumber than any of you, and secondly, with my very weak English (yes, this is all translated via Google translator) I have nothing to do in such a group, but I will be happy to watch the recordings of your meetings, especially if subtitles are available. Actually, I think this is a great idea!


    1. pprober Avatar
      pprober

      Oh, I’m so glad you spoke up, Elena. I hope it inspires others to share. I think your idea might be already happening on the http://www.puttylike.com site. That is a great place to go for multipotentialites. I appreciate what you are saying about being aware of language differences and providing subtitles and a recording. And perhaps, I ought to include something for people who are not sure they are gifted! (which is many of the folks here) You have every right to speak! Thank you!


      1. Elena Avatar
        Elena

        Thank you, Paula! I hope you find the feedback from readers around the world interesting 🙂 And thanks for the link, I’ll definitely check out the site!


  2. Clignett Avatar
    Clignett

    Ah.. the G-word.. don’t feel at all that it applies to me, really! I do forget where I parked my car, even worse, I’ve tried to open so many cars that are not mine, not understanding why it didn’t work. Even got the key out, and tried the lock.. really..

    I have never had the faintest clue what right side and left side were. Better show me, because in my mind it’s opposite. I even wrote down an entire route description to my sisters new house, years ago. Next day I had to go back, and followed my directions. Ended up calling her: “where the peep am I and how do I get to your place now?” This was before we had Google Maps on phones, so it wasn’t as easy! Turned out I wrote the whole route completely opposite. Left was right and right was left..

    On bad days I forget everything. I need my written agenda to see what I need to do or where to go and when to leave the house to be able to get there in time. Calculating Indie time before it as well.
    Written agenda because I could forget to take my mobile phone with me. Or where I left it. Need to call myself from the landline to find my mobile phone. Could be in the fridge. However it’s gotten there, I’ll never know. Indie wouldn’t do that, right? 🤷‍♀️🐶

    Just a few examples.. So I am gifted?? Really??
    Yes, I ponder, my mind wanders in all directions, I can understand many languages (some are a bit rusty to answer, but I get by), I’m crappy at math but my loosely thought out estimates are spot on (another conundrum?), I’m curious about everything (yes, everything!), I love nature and all that exists in nature (although some creepy crawlies scare the hell out of me), I’m highly allergic to wasps, I have severe hay fever all year round, and still it doesn’t keep me away. Indie loves to hike with me, especially off track, which makes it even better. And nature loves us back for it. Just this Sunday we went to a big nature park just half an hour drive from us, and while we were going off track again (Indie following his nose of course!), we were escorted by a bunch of libels, just so peaceful and beautiful! (Getting off topic again, see how my mind just wonders off in all sorts of directions? 🤦‍♀️)

    So Gifted?? Me?? There should be another word for it, besides Rainforest Mind of course. Maybe I’m multi-interested in everything? Wanting to know everything, even if it has no use in practical life or is just a bit of “just in case” situation..

    At the same time I’m trying to understand how an electrical boiler (with or without induction) works in combination with electrical heating. The technical stuff, but also the reality of it. The cost analysis in comparison to gas. It’s challenging! And nice too, to read about it, see if it is a possible solution for the gas issues and prices. Not sure if it’s the way to go, but it’s still good to read about it, trying to understand it, how it all works, technically and practically.

    (Gifted… hmph.. as Indie would answer 🤣🐶🙈)


    1. pprober Avatar
      pprober

      Sounds like you have some visual/spatial challenges, Clignett. As I’m sure you know, gifted folks are not advanced in all areas!


      1. Clignett Avatar
        Clignett

        It feels more like my mind just doesn’t understand the concept of left/right. I’m ambidextrous, maybe that has something to do with it? I don’t know. My left hand is stronger, but I write preferably with my right hand. All the rest is left sided.. strange things happen in my brain when I try to do it “the right way”..

        Special challenges, yes. More memory related than otherwise, I guess. But on the other hand I can see a room in 3-D in my mind and see what’s possible to do with it, fix it if you will.

        My brain is just strange 🤷‍♀️🤣


        1. pprober Avatar
          pprober

          🙂


        2. itssue42 Avatar
          itssue42

          A strange brain is the only way to live. Period. I would so never want to be ‘normal’.
          On handedness – have a close friend of 40 years who was beaten as a child for being left-handed, so he ended up ‘right-handed’; to this day he cannot separate left/right. Whenever he says right, I know he means left. He’s high-order autism-spectrum and definitely spatially challenged, but creative, gentle, talented, diligent etc. We are all exceptional people, us rainforesters, perfect just the way we are…..even it does drive us abso-tively freaking bonkers 😀


          1. pprober Avatar
            pprober

            🙂


          2. Clignett Avatar
            Clignett

            Oh, Sue, I just love the way you write/choose your words/how your mind thinks and works!

            It does drive me (as many of us) abso-tively freaking bonkers!

            Thank you for sharing the story of your friend. As I’m probably also somewhere on the Autism Spectrum, maybe that’s also a reason why I just can’t seem to understand the words left/right in my actions. I mean I KNOW what it means, but if you’re in a car with me and tell me to go the next turn right, I’ll go left. That’s why I love Google Maps so much, I can see an arrow pointing the direction which I’m supposed to go. Which I will probably miss, but that’s a completely different story 😂!

            No, I don’t think I’d like to have a “normal” brain, although this brain does have it’s challenges. But it’s mine, and I do really like it 😃😉😆!


            1. Ascanius Avatar
              Ascanius

              Dr. Benbow conducted research with mathematically gifted individuals, and within his group, mathematically gifted individuals were disproportionately more likely to be left-handed, have allergies, autoimmune diseases, and myopia.

              The allergies (e.g., to wasps or hay fever) and autoimmune diseases could possibly be explained by heightened sensitivity or hyperexcitability associated with the “Rainforest mind.” It’s possible that individuals with high sensitivity might experience heightened bodily reactions.

              Mathematically gifted individuals don’t think in a linear fashion but rather engage in abstract thinking. It has been found that some of them exhibit improved connectivity between the two hemispheres of their brains, featuring an enhanced corpus callosum and more white matter connecting the brain’s hemispheres. This is because the left hemisphere is responsible for basic arithmetic, while the right hemisphere handles abstract thinking. These individuals can only solve abstract mathematical problems by integrating both hemispheres. The right hemisphere is also responsible for spatial reasoning, which mathematically gifted individuals likely utilize to visualize mathematical problems better. Benbow notes that a characteristic of mathematically gifted individuals is their enhanced spatial thinking. As right-handers, they generally have a stronger right hemisphere, which means more white matter.

              Because the hemispheres are well-connected and the right hemisphere is highly developed, it’s possible for them to be ambidextrous. Simultaneously, they can also possess strong spatial reasoning skills because these abilities are associated with the right hemisphere.

              This aligns well with the Geschwind-Galaburda hypothesis, which revolves around prenatal testosterone exposure. Men have a stronger right hemisphere, while women have a stronger left hemisphere. Testosterone in the brain before birth determines the gender-specific development of the brain. More testosterone leads to better development of the right hemisphere, but it can also mean that the left hemisphere remains underdeveloped if the other hemisphere is more supplied. Because the left hemisphere is responsible for language and social functions, this could potentially lead to conditions like autism, specific learning disabilities (SLD), or a lower emotional intelligence (EQ).

              This could be connected to the established theory that highly gifted individuals have thicker myelin sheaths around their axons to facilitate faster transmission of nerve impulses. The white matter connecting the brain’s hemispheres is primarily composed of axons.


              1. pprober Avatar
                pprober

                Thank you for sharing this research, Ascanius. Is there a link you can share where some readers might find out more?


              2. Clignett Avatar
                Clignett

                Thank you, Ascanius! This makes a lot of sense, and even more so because it’s like I can feel both hemispheres connecting with each other when I’m trying to solve a problem/issue/fixing something..
                As a 3E Rainforest Mind HSP, and maybe even more, it’s a really interesting read! Can you provide links I can follow, as Paula asked?
                Again, thank you!! From me ánd my brain! 😊


                1. Ascanius Avatar
                  Ascanius

                  This text describes that both hemispheres of gifted people are well-developed and how this affects them: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258146187_Enhanced_brain_connectivity_in_math-gifted_adolescents_An_fMRI_study_using_mental_rotation

                  I made a mistake above, and it is called the empathizing–systemizing theory. It is more about the causes in brain development and also explains other characteristics that one has as a gifted person. This is only a Wikipedia article, but it still has a good overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empathising%E2%80%93systemising_theory


                  1. pprober Avatar
                    pprober

                    Oh,thank you, Ascanius. Will check these out.


                  2. Clignett Avatar
                    Clignett

                    Thank you so much! This is a really interesting study and it explains a lot. Not an “easy-read” article before going to sleep, but I’m glad I read it. Sadly it doesn’t report if the MG’s can also “feel” their brain hemispheres working together while taking the tests, but I guess that’s not a scientific thing they can prove or measure with any equipment they use.

                    The Wiki article was indeed an interesting read. Not really a big fan of Baron-Cohen myself, but it still has a few points that are good to follow up on.
                    Thanks again! 🙏


                    1. Ascanius Avatar
                      Ascanius

                      In individuals with more white matter, it can occur that brain regions responsible for processing sensory perceptions are interconnected. Consequently, synaesthesia is believed to occur more frequently in such individuals. In synaesthesia, all sorts of combinations are possible. For example, there’s ASMR, where many people are capable of perceiving it, which is also considered a form of synaesthesia, where one can physically feel sounds in the brain, or even a loud screech can be tactilely sensed. Synaesthesia can also be highly individual, leading to unconventional forms. It might involve perceiving thoughts or the activity of different brain areas through sensory impressions. Maybe the corpus callosum or the right hemisphere is connected to the brain region responsible for processing tactile stimuli.

                      However, this is only an association.


      2. Clignett Avatar
        Clignett

        special = spacial


        1. Jen Avatar
          Jen

          Yep, I’m another one that struggles with left and right! I kind of get it in my brain but when I have to move my body, it gets very confused! Again, great validation Paula.


          1. Juergen Avatar
            Juergen

            As a child I struggled with left and right, too. Then I broke my right arm and someone wrote “right” on the plaster cast. Since then I know where right is (and left) 🙂


    2. Kristen Shields Avatar
      Kristen Shields

      I still struggle with Left and Right. I’m officially Left-dominant but Right-handed (was trained into it). When I started Tae Kwon Do as an adult, this was … exceedingly difficult. But I had a lot of kids and teenagers cheering me on, which helped. 🙂 Health keeps me from furthering that practice, but I got pretty far with it! You are so not alone! (And in very 3D computer games, I get lost so fast that my family only plays with me out of pity, I think, LOL. Or if it’s not a timed event. But we have fun. Spatial is not my thing, though I’m good with visual other stuff.) Brains are just weird. ((hugs))

%d